Deep sleep during naps can spark insight and creativity

Sometimes insight strikes out of the blue – often after a nap. Now, researchers have put this brain-sleep connection to the test. In a study published in the journal PLOS Biology, Anika Löwe and her team explored how different stages of sleep influence problem-solving breakthroughs.

The researchers found that a short nap, especially one deep enough to enter N2 sleep, increases the odds of having an “aha” moment.

The study experiment included a perceptual task with a hidden trick. Most participants started with one strategy. But the clever ones found an easier route – often after taking a nap.

Sleep sparks creative insight

The study involved 90 participants aged 18 to 35. After learning the rules of a visual dot-tracking task, they were asked to rest. During this break, EEG machines monitored their brain activity. Participants were grouped into wake, N1, or N2 sleep categories.

The task, called the Perceptual Spontaneous Strategy Switch Task (PSSST), included a hidden rule. Initially, participants responded based on dot movement. Later, without warning, color also predicted correct answers. Discovering this shortcut marked the insight.

Only 70.6% of participants reached this insight. But N2 sleepers stood out. 85.7% of them figured it out. The wake group reached 55.5%, and the N1 group landed at 63.6%.

Deep sleep and brain insights

The real twist came with EEG analysis. Researchers examined the brain’s spectral slope, a marker of aperiodic activity.

A steeper slope means less background noise and deeper sleep. This steep slope correlated with more frequent insights, especially over fronto-central brain regions.

Surprisingly, traditional brain wave bands like alpha and delta did not predict insight. It was not the rhythms of sleep that mattered most, but the non-rhythmic patterns. These patterns may reflect processes like synaptic downscaling, a kind of neural reset during sleep.

How sleep may reset the brain

The idea is simple. During N2 sleep, weak synaptic connections are trimmed. This regularization clears mental clutter. It is like resetting a puzzle so your brain can see patterns it missed before. The team compared this to regularization in machine learning, which prevents overfitting.

“The EEG spectral slope has only recently been considered as a factor in cognitive processes during sleep,” said Löwe.

“I find the link between the spectral slope steepness during sleep, aha-moments after sleep and the down regulation of weights – which we identified as crucial for aha-moments in our previous computational work – very exciting.”

Naps and brain resets feel familiar

The research strikes a chord with artists and thinkers. Löwe noted that a lot of people have experienced important realizations after a short nap.

“It’s really nice to not only have data on that, but also a first direction of what processes are behind this phenomenon.”

“What really struck me when telling people in my environment – particularly creatives – about these findings was how much they resonated with people. Many of them could relate to our results with a personal experience of having a (creative) breakthrough after a nap.”

Only deep sleep boosts brain insight

The results challenge earlier studies. Some found N1 sleep, the lighter stage, to support insight. But this study’s data suggest otherwise. N1 sleep did not outperform wakefulness. Only N2 made a significant difference.

Even when accounting for subjective reports and EEG scoring methods, N2 sleep remained the best predictor.

The effect was not explained by increased alertness either. Participants in all groups performed equally well in vigilance tests before and after the nap.

Future research directions

This study opens many questions. Why does N2 sleep help so much? Can deeper sleep stages like N3 amplify the effect? How do different types of tasks respond to rest?

Löwe’s team used a visual task. Past work used math-based problems. The brain may process these differently. It is also unclear how long the nap must be. In this case, it lasted only 20 minutes.

“It’s really intriguing that a short period of sleep can help humans make connections they didn’t see before,” said study co-author Nicolas Schuck.

“The next big question is why this happens. We hope that our discovery that it may be linked to the EEG spectral slope is a good first lead.”

Löwe is a cognitive neuroscience researcher studying sleep, insight, and learning at Universität Hamburg and the Max Planck Institute for Human Development.

The study is published in the journal PLOS Biology.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–