Do birds understand language? Zebra finches reveal the answer

When zebra finches hear a call from another bird, they don’t just react on instinct. New research shows that these birds actually understand what those calls mean – in the same way that humans understand words.

This discovery changes how scientists think about bird communication. Instead of birds just reacting to sounds like a doorbell or alarm clock, they’re actually “listening” and processing meaning.

And it’s not just about mimicry or copying sounds. These birds recognize patterns, connect them to real situations, and even make mistakes that suggest they’re thinking about the meaning – not just the sound.

How zebra finches communicate

Zebra finches are small, social songbirds. They’re also very vocal. Young males learn songs from older birds, and those songs help them attract mates.

Scientists have studied these songs for years to understand how the brain processes sound.

But songs are only part of what zebra finches say. They also have other types of calls – about 11 of them – and each one has a purpose.

Some calls warn of danger, while others help them stay in touch. There are calls for courting, feeding, and even for distress. Together, they form a small but expressive vocabulary.

The secret language of birds

Even more interesting, zebra finches sometimes confuse one call for another – not because they sound alike, but because they mean something similar. That’s a big deal.

Study lead author Julie Elie is a research associate in Berkeley’s Department of Neuroscience.

“As long as call-types have clearly different meanings for the birds, they are very well distinguished even if their acoustics are quite similar. But call-types further apart in the acoustic space that can be lumped in the same semantic category are surprisingly mistaken more often by the bird,” noted Elie.

This means zebra finches are processing more than just sound. They’re forming a mental picture of what the sound means.

Studying zebra finch calls

The researchers recorded thousands of zebra finch calls – over 8,000 from more than 30 birds. They noticed the birds used specific calls in certain situations and linked each call to a behavior.

The team played recordings back to the birds, mixing them up, and rewarded the birds when they picked a specific call type.

The birds quickly learned to skip through the calls like they were flipping TV channels until they found the one with the “prize.” That told scientists the birds recognized patterns in their own language.

“This tells us that they agree with whatever organization of the repertoire we made,” Elie said. “The human is here observing and saying, ‘Those are your words.’ And the bird is saying, ‘Yes, these are my words.’”

Birds recognize the meaning of calls

One surprising part of the study: the birds didn’t always confuse sounds that were similar. Instead, they often mixed up calls that had similar meanings, even when the sounds were different.

For example, the soft “tet” call is used when birds are nearby, checking in with each other. The loud “pitchiou” (for males) or honk (for females) is used when birds are far apart.

Both mean “Where are you?” and “I’m here.” Sometimes the birds mixed those up. But they didn’t confuse either one with an alarm call, even though the alarm call sounds more like “tet” than “pitchiou.”

The results suggest that the birds group calls by meaning, not sound.

Insights into the minds of animals

This kind of mental sorting – grouping things by meaning – is something humans do all the time. We recognize that “hello” and “hi” mean the same thing even though they sound different.

If birds are doing this too, it means they’re working with mental categories, just like people.

“We have shown, indirectly, that birds understand what they are saying,” said Frédéric Theunissen, UC Berkeley professor of neuroscience.

Deeper levels of understanding

This is also the first time researchers have tested whether animals agree with the meanings assigned by human experts.

The finches confirmed it – by recognizing their own call types and showing that they hear the same categories humans do.

If zebra finches can do this, birds with more complex communication, like crows, may have even deeper levels of understanding.

“These results show that vocal communication is not entirely reflexive in birds and that there is room for decision in their vocal exchanges,” said Elie.

Birds as models for human speech

Theunissen has studied zebra finches for decades. He’s looked at how their brains process pitch, rhythm, and sound – much like how humans process speech.

Zebra finches learn their calls through experience, just like humans learn language. That makes them a strong model for understanding how vocal learning happens.

“My work was really focused on the auditory processing of communication songs versus natural sounds. What Julie brought to the lab, which was kind of an eye-opener for me, is that song is only one of the signals that they’re producing,” said Theunissen.

“If you really want to study communication systems, using just one signal that has one meaning is not the right thing to do.”

Connecting calls to bird behavior

Professor Elie has spent years studying finch calls. She even followed flocks around in Australia, recording their calls and behaviors.

She built a catalog of 11 distinct calls and connected each one to a specific action. That gave her the tools to study how birds understand and respond to their own communication.

Professor Elie also built what’s called an “ethogram,” a chart showing how each call connects to behavior.

The chart helped her design the lab experiments that proved the birds could sort and recognize different call types – and even get tripped up when meanings overlapped.

Where language lives in a bird’s brain

Now, Elie and Theunissen are digging even deeper. They’re studying the birds’ brains while the birds do these sound tests.

The researchers want to pinpoint where meaning lives in the brain. How does it tell one call from another – and what goes wrong when a bird mishears a call?

“Now we’re going from sensation to perception, to use a more psychological term,” Theunissen said. “Perception is like assigning a label, where you can actually say, ‘Oh, I am listening to a symphony or I’m hearing a bus going by in the street.’ Or here, ‘I understand what you’re speaking.’”

The experts have shown that zebra finches don’t just talk – they think about what they’re saying. That opens the door to understanding not just bird communication, but how animals in general think and interpret the world.

“By studying vocal communication, we get a better sense of the cognitive ability of animals,” Elie said. “Maybe at one point we’ll be able to communicate with other animals. If we do the effort of really deciphering their language, we might be able to understand them better.”

The full study was published in the journal Science.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–