Article image

Giant gas planets are cosmic wrecking balls that wreak havoc in habitable zones

In the cosmic game of planetary billiards, giant gas planets can act as colossal wrecking balls, effectively pushing their Earth-like counterparts out of the stable zones that might harbor life.

Two recent papers dive into this concept further, investigating the roles of giant gas planets in two distinct star systems. What they reveal might alter how we view the potential for life in other parts of the universe.

Jupiter: Gas planet is solar system’s shield

To understand the concept better, we must first look closer to home. Jupiter, the largest planet in our solar system, is more than just a spectacle for astronomers. It is literally Earth’s shield.

The giant gas planet’s substantial gravitational force acts as a deflector of potential threats, like comets and asteroids, which might have otherwise struck Earth. This gravitational behemoth ensures a level of stability that has, in part, allowed life to flourish on our planet.

However, as the new research indicates, not all giant planets are as benevolent as Jupiter.

The chaos of gas planet HD 141399

The study focuses on a star system known as HD 141399. Unique in its formation, it houses four giant planets that are positioned relatively farther from their star. This setup bears similarity to our solar system, where both Jupiter and Saturn lie at a considerable distance from the sun.

But unlike our solar system, these planets create chaos. “It’s as if they have four Jupiters acting like wrecking balls, throwing everything out of whack,” explains Stephen Kane, the paper’s author from UC Riverside. Through various computer simulations considering the data on these planets, Kane sought to determine if a planet similar to Earth could sustain a stable orbit within the system’s habitable zone.

His findings? It’s possible, but highly improbable. The immense gravitational force from the four giants would likely knock a rocky planet out of its orbit, pushing it out of the habitable zone.

The case of gas planet GJ 357

HD 141399 showcases the disruption caused by planets outside the habitable zone. A second paper investigates the potential chaos of a sizable planet located within the habitable zone. This research focuses on the star system GJ 357, located a mere 30 light years away from Earth.

Earlier studies pinpointed a planet, GJ 357 d, within this system’s habitable zone. Although previously estimated to be six times Earth’s mass, Kane’s paper titled “Agent of Chaos” posits it could be even larger, potentially ten times Earth’s mass.

Such a massive planet wouldn’t just be inhospitable for life. GJ 357 d’s gravitational influence would also likely deter other, more Earth-like planets from maintaining stable orbits in the habitable zone.

Even if a planet could maintain an orbit within this zone, its path would be highly elliptical. This would result in “wild climates,” as Kane puts it. Essentially, while a planet might be located in what we consider a “habitable” zone, the conditions could be far from conducive for life as we understand it.

Rarity of life-friendly configurations

Together, these papers underscore a profound realization. The conditions and configurations conducive to life, at least as we understand it, might be rarer than previously thought in the universe.

Kane’s concluding thoughts encapsulate this sentiment. He said, “Our work gives us more reasons to be very grateful for the particular planetary configuration we have in our solar system.”

In the quest for extraterrestrial life, it’s crucial to understand these cosmic dynamics. While the universe is vast and possibilities are endless, these findings remind us of the unique and delicate balance that enables life on Earth.

This full paper was published in the Astronomical Journal.

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and

News coming your way
The biggest news about our planet delivered to you each day