It's all in the gut: Why healthy foods work better for some people

People often eat the same fruits, nuts, or vegetables yet experience strikingly different health benefits. A major reason, scientists now say, is that gut microbes act as microscopic chemists.

Many plant compounds remain inactive until specific microbes convert them into useful forms.

A sweeping new global analysis goes further than past work, revealing just how deeply this microbial chemistry shapes nutrition.

The study shows that differences in gut enzyme “toolkits” can determine how well each person unlocks beneficial plant nutrients – and why identical diets can produce unequal results.

Gut microbes switch nutrients on

Many helpful plant molecules do not work in the form found on a plate. Gut microbes must first reshape each molecule.

Hundreds of plant compounds were tracked in recent research. The work uncovered a huge range of gut enzymes that handle this conversion step.

A large part of gut enzyme activity focuses on plant molecules. In many gut samples, over half of the enzyme pool was linked with some aspect of plant compound processing. This shows a major, hidden part of nutrition.

Everyone processes plants differently

Every person holds a different gut microbial mix. Each mix contains its own set of enzymes. Region, long-term diet, and life history shape enzyme patterns.

“Our results show how crucial microbiome function is for the effects of healthy nutrition,” said co-author Professor Dr. Gianni Panagiotou of the Leibniz Institute for Natural Product Research and Infection Biology (Leibniz-HKI).

“Only through cooperation between bioinformaticians, chemists, disease model specialists, and microbiologists were we able to capture the full diversity and dynamics of gut bacteria.”

A global survey from the Nature Microbiology study found many shared enzyme types across continents, yet personal variation remained large.

One gut sample could process far more plant molecules than another. This explains why identical meals can give unequal benefits. 

Disease limits nutrient activation

Gut microbes from chronic illness groups often lack important plant-converting enzymes. In conditions such as bowel inflammation, colorectal cancer or fatty liver, many conversion steps run at low capacity.

Machine learning models used enzyme maps to sort healthy groups from illness groups with strong accuracy. A pattern emerged. Loss of specific enzymes was often linked with poor conversion of amino acid based plant molecules, flavonoids, or aromatic acids.

Animal work added support. An anti-inflammatory plant food such as strawberry improved gut health in mice with normal microbes. Germ-free mice gained only partial benefit. Microbial enzymes appear central for full healing. 

Matching gut microbes to nutrients

Scientists studied plant-rich foods and found a huge range of plant molecules inside them. Many of those molecules could be matched with gut enzymes that change each compound into a useful form.

Some gut microbes can handle a wide mix of flavonoids and turn them into active products. Other microbes focus on only a small group of plant chemicals and carry out very specific steps.

During this work, one small set of gut microbes stood out. This group could perform conversion steps that common probiotic products cannot support.

Such steps matter because certain plant compounds stay inactive unless a microbe completes that exact change.

Knowledge like this may guide a new wave of probiotics or fermented foods. Future products may include microbe blends chosen for enzyme skills, so each blend can unlock important plant nutrients with far greater precision.

Foods designed for gut microbes

New research points toward a new type of functional food. These foods may use special gut microbes during fermentation, chosen for their strong ability to change plant compounds into active forms.

Such fermented products could help people who have low conversion capacity, meaning gut microbes cannot change plant nutrients well on their own.

This approach may be especially helpful for older groups or groups with low gut diversity, since both groups often struggle to unlock the full value of plant-rich diets.

If food makers begin to design products with microbe blends that support key enzyme steps, many communities could gain far better access to the benefits of fruits, vegetables and other plant foods.

This idea could guide future nutrition for large populations across many regions.

Your microbes shape your diet

Age, region, and life patterns shape gut enzyme sets. Older groups often show lower levels of phytonutrient-linked enzymes. Such gaps may reduce the impact of general diet rules.

Future nutrition may use stool tests to map enzyme patterns. Experts might then match plant-rich diets with gut enzyme needs or add microbe blends that support missing steps.

A clear message now emerges. Plant foods work best when gut microbes hold the right tools. Precision diet plans may soon match plant compounds with enzyme capacity for far stronger results.

The study is published in the journal Nature Microbiology.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–