Science proves that electric vehicles are much cleaner, despite the batteries

Electric vehicles don’t start out clean. Building large batteries comes with a carbon cost, so new EVs hit the road with more emissions on their ledger than comparable gas cars.

But a new analysis from Northern Arizona University and Duke University shows that this early penalty fades fast. Within just a couple of years, electric vehicles pull ahead – and once they do, they stay far cleaner for the rest of their lives.

Electric vehicle emissions shift early

The work was led by Pankaj Sadavarte, a postdoctoral researcher at Northern Arizona University. His research focuses on modeling air pollution and vehicle emissions.

The study tracked emissions from mining minerals, building vehicles and batteries, producing electricity and fuel, and driving. It follows a life-cycle – a cradle-to-grave electric vehicle emissions tally across every major stage.

Researchers found that manufacturing electric vehicle batteries creates a larger short-term carbon footprint. But the emissions advantage becomes clear within about three years – and it keeps improving over the electric vehicle’s lifetime.

Clear emissions gains emerge

During the first two years on the road, the study found that electric vehicles produce about 30 percent more carbon dioxide than gas cars because of battery production. After that point, the electric advantage grows with each mile driven.

The authors report that every additional kilowatt-hour of battery capacity cuts average carbon dioxide by about 485 pounds in 2030, then about 280 pounds in 2050. Those reductions reflect cleaner cars and a cleaner grid working together over time.

Looking across a vehicle’s lifetime, the analysis estimates that gas cars cause about two to three and a half times more environmental damage than electric cars. That comparison includes climate and air-quality damages expressed in dollars.

Cleaner grids boost EVs

Instead of freezing the power mix in place, the team used an integrated assessment model, a tool that links the energy system, economy, and emissions over decades. It lets power plants change, coal retire, and new generation enter as demand shifts.

Electric vehicles do add electricity demand, but the model shows more wind and solar joining the mix and coal shrinking as time passes. When the grid cleans up, every electric mile gets cleaner too.

For tailpipe rates, the team drew on MOVES3, EPA’s national mobile emissions model used for estimating real-world pollution from vehicles. That helps reflect how newer gas cars reduce certain pollutants over time.

Independent briefings shows that battery manufacturing emissions vary widely by factory location and energy sources. Plants powered by cleaner electricity tend to produce much lower emissions per battery.

More pollutants drop too

The model projects large cuts in carbon monoxide from switching to electric, with smaller early changes in nitrogen oxides and sulfur dioxide. By 2050, as coal falls, those pollutants drop further as well.

These gases fall under “criteria pollutants,” common harmful air pollutants the EPA regulates to protect health. Lowering them reduces smog and soot that damage hearts and lungs.

Gas cars keep emitting on every trip because combustion produces exhaust directly at street level. Electric cars shift most emissions upstream to power plants, which are easier to control with filters and standards.

What the model covers

The study did not model battery recycling or disposal at end-of-life. Recycling is improving, and using more recovered metals could lower manufacturing emissions in the future.

It accounted for well-to-tank emissions – emissions from extracting and making fuels before they reach the vehicle. That captures oil pumping, refining, and transport for gas cars.

It also considered tank-to-wheel emissions – emissions from using the fuel or electricity to move the vehicle. Gas cars emit at the tailpipe, while electric cars draw power from the grid mix available at charging.

Lessons from electric vehicle emissions

Transportation is a big slice of U.S. emissions, and decisions made today shape decades of pollution. In 2022, transportation accounted for about 28 percent of total U.S. greenhouse gases.

The two-year crossover is quick in the life of a car that often lasts well over a decade. After that point, every electric mile helps shrink both climate and air pollution burdens.

For drivers, the takeaway is simple: If reducing emissions is the goal, the clean payoff from an electric vehicle arrives early and then compounds over time.

For planners, the results tie vehicle policy to power policy. Expanding renewables and upgrading grids increases the gains that electric cars can deliver.

The study is published in PLOS Climate.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–