Ancient reefs were surprisingly empty compared to today

Reefs are usually pictured as underwater rainforests crammed with species, yet the planet’s first large animal‑built reefs tell a quieter story. New work on fossils from Nevada shows that early Cambrian seas looked nothing like the bustling coral gardens we know today.

Graduate researcher Casey Bennett of the University of Missouri and colleagues spent weeks among dusty outcrops, chipping out blocks packed with shells no bigger than grains of sand.

The analysis reveals surprising patterns of life around those ancient structures, offering a fresh window onto evolution half a billion years ago.

Animal reefs spanned ancient Nevada

More than 514 million years ago, sponge‑like archaeocyathids built the planet’s earliest animal reefs in shallow seas stretching from Siberia to what is now Nevada.

The Harkless Formation near modern Death Valley hosts dozens of these patch reefs, some only a few yards across yet stacked through hundreds of feet of limestone.

Packed between the stone cups of the sponges are fragments of small shelly fauna, the quirky menagerie of early mineralized animals that heralded the Cambrian explosion. These fossils, most under a tenth of an inch long, include baby brachiopods, snail‑like mollusks, and bristly chancelloriids.

Bennett’s team measured fossil assemblages in multiple vertical sections and compared them to the distance from reef walls.

The researchers logged grain size and chemistry of nearby layers to study how sediment influenced fossil preservation. The approach marries classic field mapping with CT scanning that can spot skeletal bits hidden in uncut rock.

That toolbox let the team count tiny creatures that earlier surveys missed, pushing sample sizes into the thousands.

Tiny fossils trace ancient reefs

Small shelly fauna crop up worldwide in rocks dating to the first 25 million years after animals evolved skeletons, making them key markers for global correlation.

Because many species lived fast and died young, their remains provide fine‑scale time stamps that help synchronize distant stratigraphic sections.

The specimens also capture evolutionary experiments that never made it into the later fossil record, such as slug‑like halkieriids that wore chain‑mail armor of overlapping plates. Linking these animals to specific habitats can explain why some lineages thrived while others fizzled.

Modern coral reefs often harbor dense banks of filter feeders and crustaceans whose larvae settle preferentially on hard walls. If early reefs played a similar ecological role, small shelly species should cluster close to archaeocyathid mounds.

That prediction has floated in textbooks for decades but rested on scant quantitative data. Bennett’s dataset provided the first rigorous test at meter‑scale resolution.

Ancient reefs didn’t increase nearby species

“With modern reefs, biodiversity is expected to decrease as you move away from the reef structure due to reduced shelter and food access,” said Bennett. Yet her counts showed no clear pattern – some distant fossil layers were as species-poor as those near the mounds.

Instead, a few hardy taxa dominate whole layers, suggesting that early oceans sorted communities by environmental filters rather than by proximity to the reef.

That pattern echoes observations from later Cambrian sections in Mongolia and Labrador, where reefs also failed to boost local diversity.

“Potentially, this happened by preferentially removing or keeping certain faunas, rather than the reef serving as a major food source for surrounding organisms,” added Assistant Professor Sarah Jacquet.

The remark points fingers at hydrodynamics – the way water flow scours or blankets parts of the seafloor. Models show gentle currents around low-relief reefs can form eddies that trap shells or carry them away. Those physics could produce patchy fossil carpets without invoking biological competition.

Sediment dictated fossil survival

The team noticed that changes in lithology, whether the rock was a grainy packstone or a micritic mud-governed which shells survived. Coarse beds preserved robust hyoliths, while fine muds favored delicate sponge spicules.

Taphonomic quirks can therefore mask true ecological signals, a warning for paleontologists who chase diversity curves through deep time. By pairing sedimentology with fossil tallies, Bennett shows how to tease apart the preservational filter.

The study also strengthens a growing view that archaeocyath reefs were short‑lived “experiments” rather than foundational keystones.

Similar conclusions emerged from carbon‑isotope work that tracked the rise and crash of reef communities through Cambrian Stage 4.

Those geochemical shifts hint that global changes in seawater chemistry, perhaps tied to oxygen pulses, played a bigger role than local reef architecture. If true, the early oceans were less a patchwork of hotspots and more a landscape ruled by large‑scale physical drivers.

Ancient reefs warn us about today

Coral ecologists note that today’s reefs often act as biodiversity magnets, with fish and invertebrate richness peaking on the reef and falling away into open sand. But those gradients may depend on the vertical relief and nutrient flow that Cambrian reefs lacked.

Understanding that difference matters because climate change is flattening many living reefs, slicing away the very architecture that supports complex food webs.

Ancient analogues show that low-relief carbonate banks can persist without the riot of life we associate with reefs. This hints at future ocean floors that remain structurally intact but are ecologically simplified.

“Just because we know how the world works today doesn’t mean it worked the same way back then,” noted Professor Jacquet. Recognizing that flex in nature’s playbook can help scientists design conservation targets that account for multiple evolutionary baselines.

Fossils show reef loss risk

Bennett plans to sample neighboring formations to see whether diversity patterns change in deeper water or in reefs built by different sponge species.

Coupling those data with fluid‑dynamic models could finally pin down how current speed and direction sculpted early animal neighborhoods.

The Nevada hills still hold miles of limestone from ancient animal reefs, awaiting fresh eyes and new technology. Every chip of shale reminds us that even the smallest fossils can rewrite big chapters in Earth history.

The study is published in the journal Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–