Japan’s obsession with otters comes at a cost

Japan loves otters and so does the internet. From squeaky coos to floating belly naps, Asian small-clawed otters have taken over YouTube and Instagram feeds. These animals show up in themed cafés, cozy up to coffee cups, and pose beside smiling tourists. It’s not hard to see why they’ve become a social media sensation.

But this viral fame hides a growing crisis. The adorable otter’s rise to stardom has come at a cost to wild populations. Behind every click, like, and share may lie a deeper story – one of trafficking, genetic decline, and fading biodiversity.

Japan sits at the center of this trade, both as a consumer and as a mirror to a broader wildlife issue across Asia.

Japan’s pet otter boom

Asian small-clawed otters, native to South and Southeast Asia, are now listed as vulnerable by the IUCN. Their populations are threatened by habitat destruction, human-wildlife conflict, and poaching.

Since 2019, they have been listed in Appendix I of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES), which bans commercial trade except in exceptional cases.

Despite this listing, the otters continue to appear in Japan’s pet stores and animal cafés. Their presence in such places indicates an active, and often illegal, wildlife trade. The allure is strong – cuddly, curious, and highly intelligent, otters are marketed as ideal companions for exotic pet lovers.

But their popularity on social media has created a feedback loop of demand that encourages continued trafficking from wild populations.

Illegal otters sourced from Thailand

To understand how otters are ending up in Japanese cafés, researchers from Kyoto University teamed up with Thai scientists.

They aimed to trace the geographic origins of the otters now living in captivity in Japan. Most attention turned to Thailand – a country previously identified as a key player in the illegal otter trade.

“Collaborative research can help identify the origins of otters kept in Japan and hot spots of illegal trade in Thailand, thus encouraging legal control in both countries,” said study first author Mayako Fujihara.

Over the last two decades, more than 100 otters have been seized at airports in Thailand and Japan. Most seizures involve multiple individuals at once, suggesting coordinated smuggling efforts.

Despite Japanese import bans and Thailand’s export restrictions, traffickers continue to find ways to move these animals across borders.

DNA links otters to wild origins

To track where the otters came from, researchers sequenced 1,511 base pairs of mitochondrial DNA from 81 captive otters in Japan.

These included individuals from zoos, aquariums, animal cafés, and customs seizures. The goal was to compare these sequences with those from known wild populations in Thailand and surrounding countries.

The analysis revealed 12 different haplotypes, grouped into three major clades. Six of these haplotypes matched wild otters from southern Thailand – areas known for coastal wetlands and hilly riparian zones.

This suggests that the majority of otters found in cafés and seized at airports had likely originated from poaching hotspots in southern Thailand.

The findings are troubling. According to the CITES trade database, no legal otter imports from Thailand to Japan have occurred since 1988. This means the otters arriving since then – including those born to trafficked individuals – have entered the country through illegal means.

Social media stardom drives demand

The modern otter craze didn’t start in a forest – it started online. YouTube channels featuring pet otters have millions of subscribers. One top channel in Japan, showing the lives of two otters, has over 1.8 million followers and a merchandise line. The same owner also runs otter cafés in major cities.

These cafés, known as exotic animal cafés, let customers play with otters while sipping coffee. They are part of a broader industry that has expanded rapidly since the early 2000s.

As of 2019, Japan hosted at least 137 exotic animal cafés, housing more than 400 species. The Asian small-clawed otter is among the most popular mammals in these cafés.

Some cafés even sell otters, with prices reaching over $10,000 per animal. In 2018, nearly half of the otters advertised for sale in Japan came from unknown sources. This lack of transparency fuels concerns about continued reliance on wild populations and unclear breeding histories.

Japan’s native otter is gone

Japan’s obsession with otters may also stem from a deep-rooted cultural memory. The kawauso, or river otter, appears in Japanese folklore as a playful and mischievous shapeshifter. But this creature was based on a real animal – the Japanese river otter, once common across the country.

Decades of hunting for fur and destruction of river habitats led to its tragic extinction. It was declared extinct in 2012 after not being seen for over 30 years.

“It is precisely because Japan’s endemic otter species has gone extinct that we aim to continue conducting research that will help protect other vulnerable species,” said Fujihara.

This extinction leaves a shadow over current efforts to protect other otters in captivity and the wild. It also heightens the urgency to prevent similar outcomes for other species caught in the trade.

Uneven diversity in captivity

One of the most striking findings from the study was the difference in genetic diversity between otters in zoos and those in cafés.

Otters in zoos and aquariums had higher genetic diversity and more varied haplotypes. This is likely due to more structured breeding programs and a larger pool of founding individuals.

In contrast, the otters found in cafés often shared just a few haplotypes. Many had been bred in-country from a narrow gene pool. Some appeared to be closely related.

This lack of diversity poses risks. Inbreeding can cause health problems and lower reproductive success. It also weakens the species’ long-term ability to adapt and survive.

Otters in zoos also came from a wider range of regions, including Peninsular Malaysia and Indonesia. This indicates legal or semi-legal acquisition before tighter regulations were in place. But many of the café otters clustered genetically with those from southern Thailand – regions known for illegal poaching activity.

Science as a shield for conservation

The study’s genetic work serves a dual purpose: it not only tracks trafficking routes but also supports captive breeding.

By understanding the genetic background of individual otters, zoos can avoid inbreeding and maintain genetic health. Otters with rare haplotypes – some found in just one or two individuals – can be prioritized for conservation.

However, mitochondrial DNA offers only part of the story. The researchers suggest that nuclear DNA sequencing could give more precise geographic information. This would allow officials to better identify the origin of seized otters and link them to specific regions.

The findings also highlight a need to build comprehensive genetic reference maps for otters across Southeast Asia. Expanding these databases would help pinpoint where wild-caught animals originate and guide future protection efforts.

Breeding for a future, not a fad

As of late 2022, Japan’s zoos and aquariums housed more than 200 Asian small-clawed otters. Many participate in coordinated breeding programs, but others still rely on imports or unverified sources. Without full genetic records, some valuable lineages may be lost.

For example, rare haplotypes found in only one or two otters could disappear without focused efforts. Losing these variants would narrow the gene pool and reduce future adaptability.

Better genetic planning, stronger import regulations, and broader cooperation between nations can help secure the future of this species. The café boom may fade, but the consequences for wildlife will last unless steps are taken now.

Japan’s love for otters has limits

Otters continue to delight audiences with their charm and antics. But behind every viral video lies a question – where did that otter come from, and what did it cost to bring it here?

If admiration leads to exploitation, then love for animals becomes dangerous. Science, policy, and awareness must align to ensure that what we adore today doesn’t vanish tomorrow.

The study is published in the journal Conservation Science and Practice.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–