Article image

Rethinking climate change: More than just higher temperatures

In the fight against climate change, the dialogue has often been narrowly focused on temperature increases, particularly in relation to the Paris Agreement targets of limiting global warming to 1.5°C or 2°C.

However, a recent study argues for a broader perspective. It contends that the emphasis on temperature alone overlooks crucial aspects of climate change.

In particular, those related to the Earth’s Energy Imbalance (EEI) and the complex dynamics of energy flow through our climate system are often ignored.

Misleading focus on temperature in climate discussions

The root cause of current human-induced climate change is primarily the heating of our planet, a result of changes in atmospheric composition due to the accumulation of greenhouse gases, notably carbon dioxide from the burning of fossil fuels.

This alteration in atmospheric composition disrupts the balance and flow of energy in our climate system, leading to diverse and sometimes extreme climate manifestations.

These include droughts, storms, flooding, and alterations in the water cycle, which are driven by the heating aspects of climate change rather than temperature changes alone.

Temperature does play a role, particularly through its effect on the atmosphere’s water-holding capacity, but it is more a consequence of these heating processes than a direct cause.

Fresh perspective on climate change

As Kevin Trenberth, the author of the new paper, points out, “Water is the air-conditioner of our planet.” Natural climate variability, such as the El Niño events, often confuses our understanding of new extremes by determining their occurrence, while human-induced changes amplify these weather events and their variability.

The focus of entities like the United Nations and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) on global temperature targets is critiqued for not fully addressing the broader aspects of climate change, including EEI.

The distinction between temperature and heating is crucial, not only for understanding climate change but also for guiding future climate control efforts through emission reductions.

Beyond the warmth to water vapor woes

Trenberth has observed the evolution of the climate change narrative, from being ignored or dismissed to being blamed for nearly every environmental disaster. He stresses the need for a more comprehensive approach to discussing climate change.

This involves recognizing the impact of increased heating on evaporation rates from oceans and land, leading to higher atmospheric water vapor levels. This, in turn, intensifies storms and increases rainfall, raising the risk of flooding.

The new climate norm characterized by a warmer ocean, less ice, changes in rainfall patterns, and potentially destabilized permafrost, underscores the importance of looking beyond global temperature metrics.

These changes, although not directly tied to global temperature, are inherently linked to the broader phenomenon of a heating climate.

Temperature to energy imbalance: Shifting the climate focus

In summary, by shifting the focus from temperature targets to a broader understanding of Earth’s Energy Imbalance and the intricate flow of energy through our climate system, we can better grasp the multifaceted nature of climate change.

This perspective illuminates the true drivers behind climate extremes such as storms, droughts, and flooding and focuses on the urgency of addressing greenhouse gas emissions more effectively.

Emphasizing a holistic approach to climate change narratives and policies, Trenberth’s work challenges us to look beyond temperature metrics and to consider the deeper, systemic changes our planet is undergoing, paving the way for more nuanced and effective climate action.

More about Earth’s Energy Imbalance

Earth’s Energy Imbalance (EEI) is a critical concept in understanding the dynamics of our planet’s climate system. At its core, EEI refers to the difference between the amount of solar energy absorbed by Earth and the amount of energy it radiates back into space.

This imbalance is a key driver of global climate change and has significant implications for weather patterns, sea levels, and ecosystems around the world.

Science behind the imbalance

Absorption and Radiation

The Earth absorbs sunlight, which is then transformed into heat, warming the planet’s surface and atmosphere. Ideally, the Earth should radiate an equal amount of energy back into space to maintain a stable climate.

However, human activities, particularly the emission of greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide and methane, have thickened the atmospheric layer, trapping more heat and disrupting this balance.

Measuring the Imbalance

Scientists use satellite observations and ocean heat measurements to quantify the Earth’s Energy Imbalance. The data collected over the past few decades indicate a steadily increasing trend, with more energy being trapped than released. This excess energy contributes to global warming, leading to a host of environmental challenges.

Impacts of Earth’s Energy Imbalance

Rising Global Temperatures

The most direct outcome of EEI is the increase in global temperatures. As the planet absorbs more energy than it emits, the overall temperature rises. This warming is not uniform, with some regions experiencing more drastic changes than others, leading to extreme weather events, including heatwaves, droughts, and intense storms.

Melting Polar Ice and Rising Sea Levels

The excess heat from EEI also contributes to the melting of polar ice caps and glaciers. This melting leads to rising sea levels, posing a threat to coastal communities and ecosystems. The loss of ice also exacerbates global warming, as ice reflects sunlight, whereas open water absorbs it, creating a feedback loop that further increases the imbalance.

Disrupted Ecosystems

The changes in temperature and weather patterns disrupt natural ecosystems, affecting biodiversity and the services these ecosystems provide. Species that cannot adapt quickly enough face extinction, while others may migrate, altering the balance of ecosystems and impacting human agriculture and livelihoods.

Mitigating Earth’s Energy Imbalance

Addressing EEI requires global efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions through the adoption of renewable energy sources, energy efficiency measures, and sustainable practices. Additionally, enhancing carbon sinks, such as forests and oceans, can help absorb more CO2 from the atmosphere, mitigating some of the impacts of the imbalance.

Implications and future study

Earth’s Energy Imbalance is a pressing issue with far-reaching consequences for our planet’s climate, ecosystems, and human societies.

Understanding and addressing this imbalance is crucial for mitigating climate change and ensuring a sustainable future for all.

Through concerted global action and commitment to reducing emissions and enhancing natural carbon sinks, we can work towards restoring the delicate balance of our planet’s energy system.

The full study was published in the journal Journal of Climate Action Research and Policy.


Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and


News coming your way
The biggest news about our planet delivered to you each day