Dog behavior is shaped by life experiences when they are puppies

The early stages of life can set the tone for a dog’s behavior. A new study of 4,497 companion dogs has revealed that stressful experiences during puppyhood are linked to greater aggression, fear, and behavioral problems later in life.

These effects persisted regardless of the dogs’ sex, age, neuter status, or origin. The results also showed that timing mattered.

Experiences in the first six months had the strongest links with behavior, and the size of those links differed by breed – pointing to biology and experience working together.

Dog behavior linked to life history

Lead author Julia Espinosa works in the Department of Human Evolutionary Biology at Harvard University (HEB). Her team collaborated with colleagues in Colorado, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Illinois on the study.

The researchers averaged item scores within the Canine Behavioral Assessment & Research Questionnaire (C-BARQ), monitoring fear and aggression scales to get summary values. Higher values reflect stronger fearful or aggressive responses across common triggers.

Analyses tested total adversity exposure, age at first exposure, and interactions with breed. The models also included clade-level ancestry categories to capture shared lineage among related breeds.

Guardians of the faithful pets reported each dog’s life history and current behavior with the validated C-BARQ, capturing patterns such as stranger-directed fear, owner-directed aggression, and separation behaviors.

The instrument showed strong reliability for tracking behavior in pet dogs and has been used widely in clinical and research settings.

Early training and dog behavior

Dog behavior has public health dimensions and consequences. In the United States, deaths from dog bites average about 43 per year, according to the CDC.

Households can lower this risk through supervision, safe handling, and early training. Matching dogs to homes that are compatible with their needs helps, too.

Puppies enter a sensitive period early in life when social contact shapes how they react to people and other animals. Behavior learned in this window tends to stick.

Stress does not affect every dog the same way. Differences in genetics, early care, and environment can tilt outcomes toward confidence or caution.

Fear and aggression in puppies

One third of dogs in the sample had some adversity in their history, including events such as physical abuse, forced tethering, or serious injury.

Dogs with adversity before six months scored higher on both fear and aggression scales than dogs without early adversity. Experiences before six months showed the largest shifts in scores.

The differences were statistically significant in linear models that also included age, sex, neuter status, body weight, weekly exercise, and household features.

The pattern held across fear and aggression subscales, with unfamiliar dog aggression as the main exception.

“The adversity-aggression association was most pronounced for events occurring in the first six months of life,” wrote Espinosa. Later adversity still mattered, but the effect sizes were smaller.

Breed and ancestry influence fear

Large among-breed differences in behavior are heritable, proving that genetics explains a meaningful share of breed-typical tendencies. This background helps define why the same stress can lead to different outcomes in different breeds.

“Our findings establish that breed ancestry and individual experience interact to show fear and aggressive behavior in pet dogs, confirming that socioemotional behavior is shaped by gene-environment interactions,” wrote Espinosa.

Ancestry can also change how dogs process stress, not just how strong a dog is or how fast it runs. Selection for certain tasks may carry along differences in thresholds for fear or assertiveness.

Knowing that makes prevention more precise. It points to early support for dogs in lineages that seem more sensitive to specific stressors.

Stress-related events and human impacts

The study did not focus on rare extremes such as abuse. It examined stress-related events that many pets can face, like being attacked by another dog, being tethered outdoors for long periods, or being relinquished and living in a shelter.

Dog guardians were then asked whether their dog had faced any of the seven adversity types. If they answered yes, their age was recorded at the first event, how often it happened, and when it last occurred.

In people, exposure to adverse childhood experiences raises the odds of many mental and physical health problems. The pattern is strongest when multiple types of adversity stack up.

Dogs live with us and share our environments, so they offer a practical way to study how early experience and biology shape behavior over time.

The findings do not label any breed as dangerous. They show that stress can push some dogs further toward fear or reactivity than others, depending on ancestry and history.

Furthermore, the results do not mean that adversity seals a dog’s fate. Training, enriched environments, and appropriate care can move behavior in a better direction.

Positive lifestyle and compatibility

Puppy socialization with patient handling, predictable routines, and positive reinforcement builds confidence. Keeping interactions low-pressure and reading a puppy’s signals prevents overexposure.

Veterinary behaviorists and credentialed trainers can tailor plans to a dog’s age, history, and triggers.

Compatibility between dogs and the households they live in also reduces friction before it starts.

Supporting dogs for better behavior

Protecting puppies from preventable stressors during the first months without avoiding normal, gentle social contact is key.

Calm, brief, well-managed encounters add up. Shelters can flag young dogs with known adverse events for extra decompression time and structured training plans.

Breeders can prioritize temperament, maternal care, and early handling practices that support resilience. Ask breeders, shelters, or rescues about a puppy’s early care and exposures.

Both can track outcomes over time. That evidence improves decision-making for placements and follow-up support.

Study limitations and future research

Surveys rely on the dog guardian’s memory and insight, which can vary. The team addressed this by requiring specific details about adversity and by modeling many other factors.

Behavior ratings still reflect daily life, not lab tests. That is a strength for real-world relevance, but it also means there are variables no study can fully control.

Larger within-breed samples can clarify which stressors most affect which lineages. Combining behavior data with genetics and physiology could reveal pathways to target with training or medication.

Longitudinal studies will help separate what early experiences do from what later environments can repair. That knowledge translates into better prevention and more humane care for your dog.

The study is published in the journal Scientific Reports.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–