Star's warped ring may be shaped by a hidden planet

Fomalhaut has long been the poster child for bright, nearby stars with spectacular debris disks. But even by cosmic standards, its dusty ring has always looked odd. 

Now, the sharpest radio images yet from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) show that the disk’s lopsided shape doesn’t just look off-center – it actually changes shape with distance from the star.

That quirk, astronomers say, is a smoking gun for an unseen planet sculpting the system from within.

Unusually dynamic debris disk

Debris disks are the messy aftermath of planet formation: belts of rock, ice, and dust left over from countless collisions among planetary embryos and comet-like bodies. 

In our solar system, the asteroid belt and Kuiper Belt are small-scale versions of the same idea. Fomalhaut’s belt, however, is vast – and famously eccentric, meaning it’s stretched into an ellipse so that its geometric “center” isn’t where the star sits.

What ALMA’s new 1.3-millimeter images reveal is that the eccentricity itself isn’t a fixed number. The ring is most stretched closer to the star and becomes progressively rounder as you move outward – an effect astronomers call a negative eccentricity gradient.

Think of Saturn’s rings if Saturn weren’t neatly centered: the inner ring segments would be more offset than the outer ones.

“Our observations show, for the first time, that the disk’s eccentricity isn’t constant,” said Joshua Bennett Lovell from the Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian. “It steadily drops off with distance, a finding that has never before been conclusively demonstrated in any debris disk.”

Is a massive planet hiding?

High-resolution imagery is only half the story. The team built a new, data-driven model to fit the ALMA images, allowing the ring’s eccentricity to vary with radius while also accounting for its width and subtle asymmetries in brightness. 

The best-fitting solution matched what dynamical theory has hinted at for years but no one had cleanly seen in nature: a steep decline in eccentricity with distance from the star.

That shape isn’t just an oddity – it’s a clue. A massive planet orbiting inside the ring can impose a gravitational pattern on the surrounding debris, forcing the inner portions into more elongated paths while exerting a gentler tug farther out.

Over time, that “shepherding” sculpts the entire belt – much like how moons corral the edges of planetary rings – into the gradient ALMA now sees.

The implication is that Fomalhaut’s disk was molded early, when the system still had a gas-rich protoplanetary disk, and has held that imprint for hundreds of millions of years thanks to the steady push-pull of the hidden planet.

Why older models fell short

A companion paper led by Johns Hopkins graduate student Jay Chittidi and published in the Astrophysical Journal Letters put the long-assumed “fixed eccentricity” approach through its paces and found it wanting. 

Comparing ALMA’s millimeter images with mid-infrared views from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), the team tracked how brightness shifts around the ring between the warm, starlit pericenter side and the cooler apocenter side.

Those shifts didn’t line up with any model that kept the ring’s eccentricity constant across its width.

“Simply put: we couldn’t find a model with a fixed eccentricity that could explain these peculiar features in Fomalhaut’s disk,” Chittidi said. 

Allowing the eccentricity to taper with distance both explained the brightness pattern and reconciled the ring’s changing width, painting a more consistent picture of a dynamically active system.

A planet you can’t see – yet

No one has directly imaged the putative planet inside Fomalhaut’s ring. A previous claim of an inner “planet” turned out to be a short-lived dust cloud. But disk architecture often betrays what hides within.

Gaps, warps, offsets, and now eccentricity gradients are the gravitational fingerprints of large bodies that are otherwise too faint or too close to the star to pick out.

Lovell and colleagues think a hefty planet – perhaps a few times the mass of Neptune or Saturn – could produce the gradient ALMA sees.

The team has already secured more observing time to test the model further, and they’ve shared their eccentricity-gradient code so others can hunt for the same telltale signature in different systems.

Why Fomalhaut matters

Fomalhaut is close, bright, and dust-rich – a perfect natural laboratory for understanding how young planetary systems evolve long after the gas is gone. Its debris belt traces the long-term outcome of countless collisions, while its shape records the gravitational choreography of whatever planets orbit inside. 

By combining ALMA’s “cold dust” view with JWST’s infrared sensitivity to warmer grains, astronomers can map not only where the material is, but also how it moves and how big the grains are in different parts of the ring.

That multiwavelength approach is crucial: different grain sizes respond differently to gravity, radiation, and gas drag (if any gas remains).

The brightness contrasts that puzzled older, fixed-eccentricity models make sense once the ring’s shape is allowed to vary with distance and the grain population is allowed to change around the ellipse.

Broader significance of Formalhaut

Fomalhaut’s eccentric ring has been the focus of intense scrutiny for nearly two decades, and it keeps giving astronomers new puzzles to solve.

The latest ALMA results shift the conversation from “the ring is off-center” to “the ring’s off-centeredness itself is structured” – a far richer constraint on any hidden planet’s mass and orbit.

More ALMA time is coming. JWST will continue to add thermal detail. And with the modeling tools now public, other lopsided rings can be checked for the same gradient signature. If the pattern shows up elsewhere, it could become a powerful, indirect way to weigh and locate planets that are otherwise beyond our reach.

For now, Fomalhaut has reminded us that cosmic “leftovers” are anything but boring. In the right light – and at the right resolution – they can sketch the outlines of entire planetary systems, including the worlds we’ve yet to see.

The study is published in the Astrophysical Journal Letters.

Image Credit: NSF/AUI/NSF NRAO/B. Saxton

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–