Article image

Being overweight makes it hard for the brain to resist unhealthy food

Let’s face it: resisting that extra slice of chocolate cake or those tempting cookies can be a real struggle. We’ve all been there. But have you ever wondered why some people seem to have an easier time making healthy choices than others? New research suggests that our body mass index (BMI) might play a role in our snacking battles. Being overweight changes brain activity and makes it harder to resist unhealthy foods.

Brain dilemma of overweight individuals

Canadian scientists from Queen’s University conducted a study to understand how the brain influences our food choices. They used MRI scans to monitor the brain activity of 123 individuals. Participants were presented with different food choices and asked to make decisions.

The researchers discovered that individuals with a higher BMI experienced significantly more mental effort when choosing healthy foods over preferred snacks.

“We examined how brain states change when making natural and regulated dietary choices in an established food task. Individuals with lower weight status could successfully modify their eating behaviours while maintaining similar modes of brain activity. Individuals with higher weight status could not rely on this mechanism,” noted the study authors.

The research highlights a concerning prediction: over 18% of the world’s adult population will likely be obese by 2025. This statistic emphasizes that many people find it challenging to maintain a healthy diet.

Brain activity of overweight individuals

The Canadian study’s key takeaway lies in how the brain orchestrates food choices in individuals with varying BMIs. Here’s a deeper dive into what the researchers may have observed in the brain scans:

Lower BMI

People with lower BMIs likely exhibited a steadier pattern of brain activity during food selection. This stability suggests their brains didn’t require a significant shift in function to prioritize healthy options.

Over time, individuals with lower BMIs might have developed well-defined neural pathways associated with healthy eating behaviors. These pathways act like established highways within the brain, making healthy choices more automatic and requiring less conscious effort.

Another possibility is that the brains of individuals with lower BMIs might show less activation in areas linked to reward processing when presented with tempting, unhealthy options. Basically, these options might not trigger the same intense pleasure response in the brain, making it easier to resist them.

For example, for someone with a lower BMI, the brain’s reward system might not light up as intensely when presented with a dessert compared to someone with a higher BMI. This dampened pleasure response could translate to a weaker craving and less difficulty in resisting the unhealthy option.

Higher BMI

The study suggests that people with a higher BMI exhibited a more significant shift in brain activity during food choices. This heightened activity indicates their brains had to work considerably harder to overcome the allure of unhealthy options and prioritize healthy ones.

Individuals with a higher BMI might experience a surge in activity in brain regions associated with cravings and reward seeking when presented with unhealthy foods. This heightened response could be likened to a stronger signal on the brain’s reward network, making it much more challenging to resist temptation.

To counteract the strong pull of unhealthy options, people with a higher BMI might need to activate areas of the brain responsible for cognitive control and decision-making to a greater degree. This increased mental effort might explain why some people find it so difficult to make healthy choices consistently.

Think of it like applying the brakes on a speeding car. The greater the temptation (speeding car), the harder the brain (driver) has to press the brakes (cognitive control) to resist the unhealthy option and choose the healthy one.

Cause and effect mystery

It’s crucial to remember that this research is correlational, meaning it shows an association but doesn’t prove that one causes the other. The researchers can’t definitively say whether difficulty with healthy choices leads to weight gain, or whether weight gain changes the brain and makes healthy choices harder. More research is needed to untangle this cause-and-effect mystery.

The study offers a fascinating glimpse into the complex interplay between brain activity and food choices. It opens doors for future research to explore potential interventions that could help people, regardless of their BMI, make healthier choices with less internal struggle.

Brain activity from being overweight

The study proves several key points:

It’s not just about willpower

For years, we’ve often been told that healthy eating is a simple matter of willpower. However, this study highlights that our biology plays a much larger role than previously understood. The brain’s response to food cues, reward signaling, and the effort required for decision-making can significantly impact our choices.

This knowledge is essential because it can help remove the stigma and self-blame that often surrounds difficulty in maintaining a healthy diet. Understanding that there’s a strong biological component can encourage a more compassionate approach toward oneself and others.

Biological component

The research doesn’t imply that people with high BMIs lack willpower. Rather, it suggests there may be underlying differences in brain wiring affecting how their brains process food choices. This difference makes resisting unhealthy options require significantly greater mental effort.

This understanding removes judgment from the equation. People struggling with their weight aren’t “weak-willed” – their brains may simply be working differently. Acknowledging this biological component fosters empathy and moves the focus away from blame.

Potential solutions for brain activity in overweight individuals

This research paves the way for developing effective and personalized strategies to help people manage their weight. Traditional approaches centered purely on willpower often fall short because they ignore this complex biological aspect.

By understanding how the brain influences food choices, scientists and healthcare professionals can develop interventions that address the root causes of the struggle. These interventions might include things like cognitive training, behavioral therapy, or possibly even targeted medications to support brain processes involved in healthy decision-making.

The study offers a beacon of hope, highlighting the potential for science to revolutionize how we approach weight management and improve dietary habits. It’s a shift towards a more supportive and solution-focused outlook.

If you find yourself struggling with cravings, don’t beat yourself up. Your brain might be working against you. Don’t underestimate the power of small changes.

Even minor shifts in your eating habits can make a long-term difference. Seek support from healthcare professionals and explore resources for healthier eating.


Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and


News coming your way
The biggest news about our planet delivered to you each day