Brain imaging, genetics, and behavior: New study redefines OCD as five distinct disorders

For decades, obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) has been treated as one diagnosis covering many different symptoms. But a sweeping new review of 121 studies suggests that approach may miss the real picture.

Researchers at the Institute of Higher Nervous Activity and Neurophysiology (IHNA) in Moscow report that OCD is better explained as five tightly related conditions. Each one is linked to its own neural circuits, genetic signatures, and cognitive traits.

The shift could reshape how clinicians understand the disorder and how they tailor treatment for the people living with it.

Five subtypes reshape OCD

Decades of independent research show four stable clusters, including contamination and cleaning, doubt and checking, symmetry and ordering, and unacceptable thoughts with mental rituals.

The review adds a fifth group focused on taboo intrusive thoughts, helping clinicians tell OCD cases apart more accurately.

People with OCD – a condition of unwanted thoughts and repetitive actions – often feel trapped by a cycle of fear and relief. Symptoms can consume hours each day and push aside school, work, and relationships.

The review organizes findings across the five groups without mixing them into a single average. That design lets differences stand out instead of being lost in the noise.

Distinct brain signatures emerge

One functional magnetic resonance imaging study showed distinct activity maps for washing, checking, and hoarding triggers.

“OCD may be best conceptualized as a spectrum of multiple, potentially overlapping syndromes rather than a unitary nosologic entity,” said D. Mataix-Cols, the study’s lead author.

Contamination and cleaning concerns often stir the insula, which helps encode disgust and bodily unease. Symmetry and ordering more often recruit sensorimotor networks that judge whether actions feel complete.

Taboo, intrusive thoughts tend to engage emotion-focused frontal areas and the amygdala. That matches how intensely shame and threat can register when those images strike.

Genetic clues behind OCD

Under the surface, brain cells talk using neurotransmitters, chemical messengers that carry signals between neurons in the brain. Evidence suggests that glutamate, serotonin, and dopamine play different roles across the five groups.

One glutamate transporter gene called SLC1A1 has been tied to the condition in families and population samples. The signal is strongest when hoarding features are present, pointing to an altered balance in excitatory signaling.

A well-known enzyme variant, the COMT Val158Met genotype, shows up more often when hoarding is the dominant problem. Lower enzyme activity can raise dopamine tone in the frontal cortex, which tracks with difficulty switching gears.

Serotonin-related variants may be more common in people with symmetry and ordering compulsions. A growth factor signal called brain-derived neurotrophic factor may also affect how threat memories stick or fade with practice.

Signals tying brain to action

Scientists use the word endophenotype – a measurable trait that links genes to symptoms – to describe mid-layer signals that bridge biology and behavior. Examples include reaction-time patterns, brain-wave rhythms, and resting-activity maps in specific circuits.

Across the five groups, certain traits repeat enough to be clinically useful. People who check a lot report more doubt about mistakes, while those drawn to symmetry often report a nagging sense that things are not “just right.”

Some cognitive tests also split by group. Planning, inhibitory control, and flexible thinking vary in small but consistent ways that match the main complaint.

Taken together, the signals across imaging, genetics, and behavior point in the same direction. The five groups look distinct at each level of analysis.

New paths for OCD therapy

Medication that boosts serotonin remains a standard first-line treatment. Many people benefit and then relapse less, but some still need more help.

The most supported talk therapy is exposure and response prevention, a form of cognitive behavioral therapy that teaches new habits by facing triggers without rituals.

Evidence across symptom dimensions shows solid gains, with special planning needed for taboo-thought cases.

Knowing the leading subtype can shape what to try first and how to adjust. A person high in symmetry and ordering may need exercises that target not just fear, but the drive for exactness and the relief of a “just right” feeling.

When hoarding is central in this condition, clearer decisions about possessions often require slower pacing and choices in the actual home.

When unacceptable thoughts dominate, sessions may spend more time on shame, guilt, and hidden mental rituals.

Next steps in OCD research

The five-group map is not a label to carve in stone. People carry mixes of symptoms, and the pattern can shift over time.

Still, the categories are steady enough to plan better studies and treatment trials. A clear map also helps families understand why two people with the same diagnosis can respond to very different tools.

Future work will test whether blood-based markers or task-based brain signatures can sort people before treatment begins. That step could speed recovery by matching strengths and needs from day one.

Clinicians also need screening questions that catch hidden rituals in unacceptable thoughts. Early recognition can prevent months of confusion and delayed care.

The study is published in the International Journal of Molecular Sciences.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–